Which Car?

We are still on the hunt for a new car in preparation for the demise of the 150,000 miles plus Nissan Sentra. Trucks are definitely out even though I really like the Ford grill but gas mileage is on the top of the priority list. We are thinking about the Prius hybrid as much as I dislike the look of that car, and the Dodge Vibe. One year old cars of either model will be great But I doubt there will be any used Prius cars out there. If anyone knows of good mileage cars with high marks from Consumer Reports, please point me in that direction.